Is This Any Way to Run A Democracy?
Tuesday night’s City Council meeting was a cross between Samuel Becket’s “Waiting for Godot” and the Abbott and Costello “Who’s on First?” routine.
The Council was charged with appointing someone to replace Council member Herb Katz who died shortly after being re-elected last fall.
If the members failed to agree on a replacement or chose not to make the appointment, they would have to call for a special election and leave the decision to the voters.
Bobby Shriver, the only member of the Council who remained rational and consistent through the witless exercise, repeated a proposal he made at a previous meeting – that a special election be held so that the people could elect their representative themselves and he or she would not be beholden to anyone but the people.
Several Council members protested, citing the estimated $100,0 00 cost of a special election . Shriver said $100, 000 out of a $500 million budget was not too much pay for a vote of the people.
He added that if his colleagues refused to call a special election, he would vote e to appoint Ted Winterer, who ran fifth in the fall election.
Mayor Ken Genser then delivered a dissertation on the number of votes other also-rans in earlier elections had got, and the percentages of the whole vote they got, which, by his lights, was more significant.
Though he didn’t admit it, his point was that Winterer was not only no more qualified than anyone else, but less qualified than some. His theory was as dubious as his lecture was dull. It was also pointless as at least half the people in the room knew that he was trying to clear the way for Patricia Hoffman in advance of the vote.
Hoffman, like Genser and three other Council members are Santa Monicans for Renters’ Rights (SMRR) stalwarts. Winterer is not.
Not to be outdone in the tedium department, mayor pro tem Pam O’Connor (also a SMRR) paid tribute to herself for taking the time out of her busy schedule to “speed-date” the 27 people who had “applied” for the Council vacancy.
Then, after the usual self-serving flimflam from the other two Councilmen from SMRR, Richard Bloom and Kevin McKeown, the voting got underway.
McKeown nominated Winterer, Genser nominated Hoffman, and O’Connor nominated Gleam Davis. All three had made unsuccessful runs for City Council, but Winterer was the only one who had run last fall and taken positions on all the current issues, Davis and Hoffman are the co-chairs of (SMRR).
Shriver and Councilman Bob Holbrook voted with McKeown for Winterer on the first round. Seven or eight rounds followed. Shriver held fast, voting for Winterer through all eight rounds, while occasionally reiterating the need for a special election.
McKeown jumped back into the SMRR camp after a few rounds. Then Holbook abandoned Winterer. The four SMRRs then bounced Davis and Hoffman votes around until Genser abandoned Hoffman in favor of Davis.
In fact. she could have won without his vote, as she had the votes of the other three SMRRs and Holbrook.
When Genser abandoned Hoffman \to vote for Davis. Holbrook tried to change his vote from Davis back to Winterer. But it was too late.
Davis immediately took the oath of office and joined her new colleagues on the dais. SMRR now has a five-two majority, which, in effect, renders Shriver and Holbrook redundant.
Is this any way to run a democracy?
Of course not. But this isn’t a democracy, this SMRRland.





I am a SMRR supporter. I have been since they began, even though I’ve disagreed with them at times. I know that they are
really the only group working hard to protect renters rights and promote affordable housing. I sincerely thought Ted Winterer
actually was a SMRR member. And ,I actually wish Councilmembers Holbrook and Shriver would join and support SMRR.
I’m sure Gleam Davis will be an excellent Councilmember. And I’m glad we followed our City Charter and now do not have to
go through another divisive, expensive and untimely election.